2.17.2006
Columbia Study Suggests High IQ Hides Alzheimer's
>
Researchers at Columbia University assert that mild cognitive impairment is hidden by education. This indicates a need for highly sensitive cognitive measures, unlike animal names, counting backwards, or the MMSE - all non-interactive, subjective, paper-based tests.
A study at Columbia University Medical Center suggests high IQ and more years of schooling may only camouflage the disease process. The educated brain seems to protect itself against symptoms early on, but once symptoms surface, scientists say there is a faster rate of decline.
"When symptoms finally do appear, their brains are already overwhelmed by the pathological disease process," said Dr. Nikolaos Scarmeas, assistant professor of neurology and lead author of the study published this month in the Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry.
The scientists have been studying thousands of people older than 65 in Manhattan. The 312 men and women did not show signs of Alzheimer's when they entered the study, but a year and half later the first symptoms developed. The scientists have followed them for more than five years.
At the study's start, everyone completed neuropsychological tests, and the scientists spent an hour examining each patient. They also obtained medical records. Among participants, there was a range of ethnicities, and education varied from no formal schooling to 20 years of it.
"We think that these people can tolerate more changes and maintain their cognitive performance for a longer time," Scarmeas said of those with the most education.
"The extra reserve capacity of the smart brain makes a person look like they don't have a disease," said James Mortimer, a professor of epidemiology and biostatistics at the University of South Florida in Tampa. "But the disease is a lot further along by the time the person is diagnosed."
The problem, he added, is that as scientists get better at treating the disease, "we need to find these people earlier. If they are hiding behind their education, we can't do that. We won't find them in time."
No one knows why education appears to soften the symptoms. It could be that smarter people do more mental exercise. It may be that they have a variety of cognitive strategies when solving problems.
A study at Columbia University Medical Center suggests high IQ and more years of schooling may only camouflage the disease process. The educated brain seems to protect itself against symptoms early on, but once symptoms surface, scientists say there is a faster rate of decline.
"When symptoms finally do appear, their brains are already overwhelmed by the pathological disease process," said Dr. Nikolaos Scarmeas, assistant professor of neurology and lead author of the study published this month in the Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry.
The scientists have been studying thousands of people older than 65 in Manhattan. The 312 men and women did not show signs of Alzheimer's when they entered the study, but a year and half later the first symptoms developed. The scientists have followed them for more than five years.
At the study's start, everyone completed neuropsychological tests, and the scientists spent an hour examining each patient. They also obtained medical records. Among participants, there was a range of ethnicities, and education varied from no formal schooling to 20 years of it.
"We think that these people can tolerate more changes and maintain their cognitive performance for a longer time," Scarmeas said of those with the most education.
"The extra reserve capacity of the smart brain makes a person look like they don't have a disease," said James Mortimer, a professor of epidemiology and biostatistics at the University of South Florida in Tampa. "But the disease is a lot further along by the time the person is diagnosed."
The problem, he added, is that as scientists get better at treating the disease, "we need to find these people earlier. If they are hiding behind their education, we can't do that. We won't find them in time."
No one knows why education appears to soften the symptoms. It could be that smarter people do more mental exercise. It may be that they have a variety of cognitive strategies when solving problems.
